Skip to main content

Rewrite of fiducial detector

Its the last thing I want to do - I've roughed out code for most of the UI elements, the plumbing for the back-end works (although you can hear it rattle in places and there is considerable scope for improvement) but the marker detection code just isn't up for to the job and is getting a rewrite to use camshift and a Kalman filter. I tried the Kalman on the current code and its effective in smoothing the jitter caused by variations in centroid position but the continual loss of marker and the extreme numbers I am having to use to sense when the markers are engaged/unengaged is making it a frustrating experience.

I MUST come up with something working by Monday so that I can do something with this and was hoping to be tweaking various parameters of the interaction today but I'm going right back to stage one. Very frustrating but I ran a few experiments with the camshift algorithm and feel its required to make the air-writing implementation flow smoothly.

All nighter it looks like then :(

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I know I should move on and start a new blog but I'm keeping this my temporary home. New project, massive overkill in website creation. I've a simple project to put up a four page website which was already somewhat over specified in being hosted on AWS and S3. This isn't quite ridiculous enough though so I am using puppet to manage an EC2 instance (it will eventually need some server side work) and making it available in multiple regions. That would almost have been enough but I'm currently working on being able to provision an instance either in AWS or Rackspace because...well...Amazon might totally go down one day! Yes, its over-the-top but I needed something simple to help me climb up the devops and cloud learning curve. So off the bat - puppet installation. I've an older 10.04 Ubuntu virtual server which has been somewhat under-taxed so I've set that up as a puppet master. First lesson - always use the latest version from a tarball unless you have kept t...
Post a Comment
Read more

New Detector Done

Much better but I'm still not happy with it - camshift + backproj + kalman means that the marker coordinates are a lot smoother with far less noise (obviously) but the nature of detecting markers in segmented video still leads to a less than robust implementation. There's room for improvement and I still need to add in some form of input dialog for naming markers (and I must confess I am CLUELESS on the c++ side for that.....wxwidgets? Qt?) but I'm that little bit happier. As per usual I had hoped for a video, but the lack of a dialog makes configuring things into a manual process (I've got basic save/load support working but given how sensitive this is to lighting still its a lot of messing around) hence I'm delaying yet again. Given my page views though I don't think I will be disappointing many people. What is frustrating is the amount of time I've had to spend on basic work with computer vision rather than looking at the actual interactions for this ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Finally...

Children back at school and I'm back off my hols (a rather interesting time in Estonia if you're interested). I've spent most of the last week becoming increasingly frustrated with my attempts at image segmentation. I've moved to a c++ implementation for speed and, while the VERY simplistic HSV segmentation technique I am using works, the problem is that I cannot get it to work robustly and doubt that it will ever do such. I've now covered the range of available techniques and even tried to plumb the depths of just emerging ones and it seems that every computer vision based object tracking implementation or algorithm suffers for the same issue with robustness (openTLD, camshift, touchless, hsv segmentation and cvBlob etc etc). YES, it can be made to work, but issues include (depending on the algorithm) : - Object drift : over time the target marker will cease to be recognised and other objects will become the target focus. - Multiple objects : During segments...
Post a Comment
Read more